Althing and lawthing in Orkney
Doreen Waugh has suggested two other likely district assembly sites: Hoxa on South Ronaldsay and Doomy Hill on Eday. Hoxa appears in the Orkneyinga Saga as Haugaeið, ‘the isthmus with the mounds’ and the Saga also tells us that this is where Earl Thorfinn Skullsplitter was buried in the 10th century. These features support the idea that Hoxa was indeed a thing site, as in Scandinavia these sites were frequently located in burial grounds and by isthmuses. The name Haugaeið is moreover similar to Scandinavian thing names. Doomy is derived from Old Norse dóm-eið, ‘the judgement isthmus’, and Doomy Hill may therefore have served as a marker for a thing site. Most likely there were other district things as well, but they are rather tricky to identify. Instead I am going to examine the thing sites at the top of the hierarchy, the lawthing and its likely predecessor, the althing. The althings were the general assemblies for all free men, and were later replaced by lawthings, representative assemblies where royal law was introduced and enforced. In Shetland and the Faeroes the transition between the two seems to have taken place at the end of the 13th century and the beginning of the 14th century, and it may have been the same for Orkney.
There is no unequivocal mention of an Orkney althing, but as althings formed an integral part of the thing organisation it would be very surprising if Orkney did not have one. And there is indeed one possible reference to an althing in the Saga. We are told that the thing meeting between Earl Magnus and Earl Hakon (where their Egilsay meeting which led to Magnus’ death was arranged), took place on the ‘Mainland, where the people of Orkney had their place of assembly’. This is generally seen to refer to Tingwall in Rendall (or sometimes Birsay), but the wording in the Saga suggests it may well refer to an althing. Moreover, a meeting of this magnitude, between two Orkney earls, would most likely have taken place at the althing.
Documents from the 15th and 16th centuries state that lawthing meetings were held in Kirkwall. According to the Saga, thing meetings were held in Kirkwall long before this time, although their exact location is not stated. The only meeting specifically mentioned is said to have taken place in the 12th century; in the time of Rognvald Kali Kolsson (d. 1158). The sagas also mention two arbitrations (Old Norse sátt or sætt) that took place in Kirkwall. One is the reconciliation between Earl Rognvald and Earl Paul at an unknown place in Kirkwall and the other a peace meeting between Earl Rognvald and Svein Asleifarson in St Magnus Cathedral. Arbitrations were private settlements which should be held away from the thing site, and the cathedral is therefore an unlikely place for the Kirkwall thing.
According to local tradition this was instead found in the spot where Albert Street and Bridge Street meet today. This place is now known as Parliament Close and this is supposedly where the Scottish Parliament met during the visit of King James V in 1540. As the street name implies, there was here a bridge across the Papdale Burn. Today’s Parliament Close is also near the 11th-century St Olaf’s Kirk and in the area where the earliest Norse settlement in Kirkwall has been traced. Altogether, this seems a likely location for the thing, as these sites were often situated by fresh water, crossing points, landing places and sometimes churches. In terms of location, Kirkwall in general is a very likely place for an assembly as it is easily accessible from two directions and was also situated on an isthmus – Scapa comes from Old Norse Skálpeið, which according to Hugh Marwick means ‘long valley isthmus’ or ‘the isthmus cleaving the Orkney Mainland in two’.
The althing site is unlikely to have been located in Kirkwall, despite the lawthing being there, perhaps from c. 1300. The althing presumably existed long before the establishment of Kirkwall and these sites tend to be found in very striking places, often with older archaeological remains, such as Old Uppsala in Sweden with its three large burial mounds and other major features. One possible location of an Orkney althing is Maeshowe. In the Saga this goes under the name of Orkahaugr. Berit Sandnes has pointed out that an early Irish name for Orkney was Innsi Orc = ‘Islands of the pigs’ and Maeshowe can therefore be translated as the ‘mound of the pigs’. Orc was probably a tribal name for the Orkney Picts and also lies behind the Old Norse name Orkneyjar, but here the Celtic orc has been replaced by the Norse orkn, which means grey seal – and ‘Seal islands’ is of course a very fitting name for Orkney. The Vikings are likely to have seen Orkahaugr = ‘the mound of the pig people’ (the Picts), as a suitable name for the Orkney althing. The different linguistic roots of Orkahaugr and Orkneyjar did presumably not matter and were most probably unknown among the population.
It is extremely difficult to decide which of the two names Orkahaugr or Maeshowe is the older. The name Maeshowe is also of Old Norse origin and does not dispute the idea of this having been a thing site. The form Mesow is recorded from the 1760s and can be translated as ‘the meadow mound’. The first element is an Old Scandinavian word *mað = ‘meadow’. This name reminds us of assembly place-names in Scandinavia, which frequently refer to managed lands of different kinds, and indeed also Rendall’s Tingwall, which translates as ‘Thing field’. It is important to point out, however, that it is not necessary for a thing site to have a name containing the element ‘thing’, indeed there are a great number of Scandinavian sites that do not.
We know that the Norse used Maeshowe for some purpose. The 12th-century runic inscriptions inside the tomb demonstrate this clearly, while the Orkneyinga Saga suggests that Maeshowe had a special place in the minds of the Norse. We are told that Earl Harald’s men hid inside the chamber during a blizzard and at least two men are said to have lost their mind. More compelling evidence is that the bank surrounding the mound seems to have been rebuilt around AD 950. This shows that the Norse maintained the monument and made sure its features were in good order. This is a trait which I have seen in my work on assembly sites in other areas. The most interesting example is Scutchmer Knob, a Bronze Age mound, in Berkshire, England. This functioned as a shire assembly site in the late Anglo-Saxon Period (the 10th and 11th centuries). Here the ring ditch surrounding the assembly mound had been re-cut three times, and in this way the monument was re-defined on quite a substantial scale.
In terms of location, Maeshowe is ideal as a major assembly site, located more or less in the centre of Orkney and accessible from many directions. Indeed the natural walking routes through the Orkney Mainland pass this site. This is illustrated by the saga episode with Harald’s men who stopped at Maeshowe, as they were in fact on their way from Stromness to Firth. Moreover, if Barbara Crawford’s idea of Norse water routes through parts of the west Mainland holds true, the accessibility of Maeshowe would have been even greater.
The monument’s striking appearance also means that it would have fitted the Viking’s ideas of althing sites well, and we have several other examples of the Vikings in Scotland reusing turf-covered mounds for their thing sites. The place-name Brodgar may add further to the likelihood of Maeshowe being an assembly site. Brodgar means ‘bridge farm’, and as I said earlier bridges and crossing points are commonly found close to thing sites. Finally, the legal traditions where couples could get married by holding hands through the hole in the Odin Stone and – if they later changed their minds – get divorced by walking through Stenness Kirk and exiting by different doors, strengthen the area’s judicial roots.
The story of Orkney’s thing sites does not end here. I will be back next month to tell you more about the Kirkwall thing and what happened to this after the end of the Norse period. If you are interested in hearing more about thing sites and about the Orkney Vikings generally, why not sign up for our summer school? We would love to see you there!
Dr Alexandra Sanmark, CNS
Published in The Orcadian 01/03/2012